How to choose the best winter tires? Pros and cons of Cordiant, Nokian, Nordman, Amtel, compare, choose
Content
It is difficult to say which winter tires are better, Cordiant or Nokian, because. both manufacturers are popular with the domestic buyer. Companies take a responsible approach to the development of tire products, paying close attention to the high quality of products.
Winter is a real test for drivers. Severe frosts and snowfalls force vehicle owners to put winter tires on the wheels, the tread of which helps to avoid skidding on ice and subsidence in deep snow. "Cordiant" - economical tires of a Russian manufacturer. Rubber of this brand - decent quality at a low price. So is it worth overpaying for more expensive brands - which winter tires are better: Cordiant or Nokian, Nordman, Amtel.
Winter tires Cordiant or Nokian - what to choose
To understand which winter tires are better, Cordiant or Nokian, let's compare the rubber compound, road grip, acoustic comfort and a number of other parameters.
Cordiant tires: features
The assortment of winter tires "Kordiant" includes 4 types of winter tires and covers the market in more than 30 countries. The domestic brand occupies a leading position in sales in the countries of Eastern Europe. In the Russian market, the company has an honorable 3rd place.
Tires "Cordiant"
The advantages of winter tires "Kordiant" are:
- low price and good level of grip with the track;
- no pressure loss with temperature dynamics;
- unique tread patterns that differ on different winter models.
Despite the positive features, there is a significant negative factor. Russian-made tires have not been modified for a long time. At the same time, Finnish Nokian tires have undergone a number of changes since their release to increase the degree of grip performance.
About Nokian tires
Nokian is the largest Finnish tire manufacturer. In Russia, models of this brand are produced by the Vsevolzhsky plant. In terms of sales in the domestic market, Nokian products take 7th place. For Russia, the company produces exclusively "shoes" for the wheels of premium cars.
Nokian tires
The main advantages of brand tires:
- a wide range of winter tires, including 11 different models;
- a wide variety of sizes;
- excellent grip and performance.
Models of these tires are tested in the Scandinavian countries and the Russian Federation, where they demonstrate consistently high results. Nokian regularly take prizes in the fight against global brands.
What do tires of Russian and Finnish companies have in common
Both manufacturers produce tire models for the Russian market (domestic roads and bad weather). In the assortment, in addition to winter, there is also summer tires. Other common features:
- companies produce studded and friction type winter tires (Velcro);
- produce tire sizes for all types of vehicles;
- occupy a leading position in sales in the domestic market;
- develop tire models using innovative technologies and test them at the world's largest testing grounds.
It is difficult to say which winter tires are better, Cordiant or Nokian, because. both manufacturers are popular with the domestic buyer. Companies take a responsible approach to the development of tire products, paying close attention to the high quality of products.
The best models of winter tires "Cordiant"
Among the Cordiant tires for winter, the top samples are the following:
- Cordiant WinterDrive. Friction type tires. They have been produced since 2012, but are still relevant to this day, since they adequately prove themselves on winter tracks in various regions of the Russian Federation. The absence of studs is compensated by an effective tread pattern that provides a high level of grip.
- Cordiant Snow Cross. Studded tires for use in severe frosts. Holds the icy track perfectly, demonstrating good grip and maneuverability. The tread pattern in the form of a longitudinal rib and side rectangular blocks provides additional vehicle stability. Has a two-layer structure. The bottom layer is stronger and more rigid, which guarantees resistance to deformation, and the top layer is soft and elastic, which ensures a smooth ride.
- Cordiant Sno Max. The tread of these studded tires is a zigzag block, dotted along the edges with numerous sipes. This pattern is well suited for use on icy and snowy off-roads. When driving on wet asphalt, the result is worse - the length of the braking distance and fuel consumption increase.
- Cordiant Polar 2. This model belongs to the next generation of Cordiant Polar 1 tires. Tires are designed to "shoe" the wheels of crossovers and SUVs. The tread pattern is directional, and its central part is made in the form of a longitudinal, zigzag rib. Products are made from a special rubber compound that does not lose elasticity in severe frosts.
- Cordiant Polar SL. They demonstrate excellent grip on icy road surfaces. These tires are most suitable for urban conditions. The quality of driving on wet pavement is much worse due to the lack of spikes.
The best Nokian winter tires
The three most popular models are:
- Hakkapeliitta 9. Studded tires for driving on snow and ice. Tires are distinguished by excellent directional stability, acoustic comfort. Suitable for driving on snow and ice in urban areas. They behave a little worse on wet pavement.
- Hakkapeliitta R3. Friction type tires, most suitable for driving on snow. On the ice, the car skids a little. However, this problem applies to all cars, "shod" in non-studded tires.
- More budgetary tires, in comparison with the previous samples. Type - Velcro. More suitable for driving on wet asphalt. In deep snow they slip, but with adequate driving, they cope with a snowy road.
Summing up the results: what to buy, "Cordiant" or "Nokian"
It is not entirely correct to compare which winter tires, Cordiant or Nokian, are better, since both representatives are in different price categories. The domestic manufacturer loses to the Finnish company in all respects, except for the price. The main choice is based on the financial capabilities of the car owner. If funds allow, it is more expedient to choose Nokian. For those who want to save money, but sacrifice quality, Cordiant tires are suitable.
Which tires are better: Amtel or Cordiant
The products of both manufacturers belong to the budget segment.
What do winter tire brands have in common?
Like Kordiant, Amtel tires are very popular with Russian motorists. When developing tires, similar technologies are used to improve driving comfort on the roads of the Russian Federation.
What is the difference
Let's try to determine how winter tires are better - Amtel or Cordiant. Cordiant tires are produced by a Russian holding company. Amtel is a Russian-Dutch company, part of whose shares are owned by the world famous Italian corporation Pirelli.
Tires "Amtel"
Winter tires "Cordiant" or "Amtel": which is better to choose
Tires NordMaster Evo ("Amtel") demonstrate acceptable grip. The tread pattern consists of longitudinal and transverse rectangular blocks covered with spikes and numerous sipes. The structure of the pattern is aimed at quickly removing moisture, snow and dirt.
Cordiant outperforms its competitor in a number of significant ways:
- manageability;
- patency;
- coupling on snowy and icy roads;
- acoustic indicators.
If we talk about which winter tires are better, Amtel or Cordiant, most buyers prefer the second manufacturer. However, given the budget NordMaster Evo and acceptable performance, they are not far behind the opponent. At the same time, Amtel tire models can often be seen on premium cars.
What to choose: Cordiant or Yokohama
Yokohama is a Japanese company that has been a leader in the tire market for many years. The rubber of this brand is superior to Cordiant in a number of operational and technical aspects. It is also known that the Russian manufacturer borrows technology for making “shoes” for wheels from an opponent and copies the tread pattern on some winter models.
Pros and cons of winter tires "Cordiant"
Winter tires Kordiant meet all international standards of quality and driving comfort. Products are manufactured on modern equipment and tested by means of computer simulation.
Motorists are well aware of the affordable price and adaptation of Cordiant tires to the specific road conditions of Russia. Tires are enough for 3-4 seasons of operation, they retain grip even in severe frosts. Among the minuses, buyers note the noise of studded rubber, insufficient grip on ice with Velcro.
Pros and cons of Yokohama winter tires
The eminent Japanese company produces 6 types of winter tires:
- Ice Guard IG55;
- Ice Guard IG 604;
- Ice Guard IG50+;
- Ice Guard SUV G075;
- Drive V905;
- Drive WY01.
The range includes 1 studded and 5 friction types of tires. The main disadvantages of winter tires from a Japanese company are a weak cord on some models, unpredictable behavior in a rut, and an overpriced price.
The tread of the studded winter tires Yokohama Ice Guard IG55 is covered with special high-strength studs with a figured body and transversely oriented "dumbbell" inserts. The directional tread pattern is both an advantage and a disadvantage of such wheels. Its structure provides maximum traction, but drivers note that when driving in wet snow, the wide slots in the pattern quickly clog.
Tires "Cordiant" and "Yokohama": which are better
Tire brands differ in the composition of the rubber compound. Japanese products are made from a higher quality polymer substance with a high concentration of silica, which increases adhesion and wear resistance. Orange oil is also added to the mixture, which retains elasticity at very low temperatures.
Yokohama tires
If we talk about which winter tires are best suited for Russian roads, Cordiant or Yokohama, everything is decided by price and quality. The Japanese brand offers expensive, but time-tested products of the highest level, surpassing the competitor in all respects. Therefore, if there is money, most car owners prefer Japanese tires.
