Niu, Piaggio, Unu, Govets: comparison test of 7 ADAC electric scooters
Content
A recognized authority in Germany, ADAC has tested and compared seven electric scooters of different brands, categorized as 50cc equivalent. See Even though prices for some models are in excess of 5000 euros, none of them have been able to fully convince.
« Ok, but it could have been better ... “It is in this spirit that one can summarize the test results published by ADAC, a German federation especially influential in the automotive world that tests various electric scooters on the market every year.
Govech, Piaggio, Unu, Torroth, Kumpman, Vassla and Niu. A total of seven different brands of electric scooters were evaluated by ADAC teams for this 2019 session, thus measuring the autonomy, charging time, ergonomics and comfort of each model.
Niu N1S - best value for money
Unless it ranks at the top of the rankings with an overall score of 3,1/5 (best score is zero), the Niu N1S offers the best value for money, according to ADAC. Selling for less than 3000 euros, the Chinese manufacturer's electric scooter captivates with its modern design, connectivity and autonomy. However, it disappoints with low load ratings and the quality of the braking system.
Piaggio Vespa Elettrica and Govecs Schwalbe, rated "good" with their respective ratings of 2,5 and 2,3/5, are performing better, but ADAC teams deemed them too high a selling price.
On the contrary, the 1954 Kumpan received a heck of a slap in the face. The Kumpan electric scooter, which ranks last despite its cost approaching 5000 euros, has been criticized for its poor lighting system, software flaws, low autonomy and too high a price compared to competitors.
No perfect model
In the end, ADAC will not single out any of the tested electric scooters in the "very good" category.
A conclusion that an organization justifies in its press release. ” The best scooters are characterized by high autonomy, low power consumption and short charging times. " he considers.
For the German organization, the best solution to overcome the limited autonomy of modern electric scooters is to offer a removable battery device. A system offered by five of the seven models tested. ADAC also considers modularity to be important as some vendors offer additional packages. That to extend autonomy and better adapt to the needs of everyone, without reducing the initial price due to oversized battery packs.
After-sales service worth considering
For anyone considering buying an electric scooter, ADAC invites you to be vigilant in terms of service. Many manufacturers only have repair services in major cities, the agency warns. The latter reminds in passing that consumers should "definitely" try before buying.
To find the full ADAC test, go to the organization's official website. German is the only language available, don't forget to bring an interpreter with you 😉
Electric Scooter Test: 2019 ADAC Ratings
| Global sign | Solution | |
| Swallow Govets | 2,3 | Good |
| Piaggio Electric | 3,5 | Good |
| Nest N1 S | 3,1 | Satisfactory |
| Torrot Fly | 3,2 | Satisfactory |
| Vasla 2 | 3,3 | Satisfactory |
| One Classic scooter | 3,5 | Satisfactory |
| Companion 1954 | 4,9 | Facilities |
